ECOTOXICOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT OF WASTE SCRUBBER WATER IN UNICELLULAR ALGAE (TETRASELMIS SUECICA) AND BLUE MUSSEL (MYTILUS EDULIS) LARVAE

---

• Available online in Detritus - In Press

---

Abstract

Marine scrubbers can be classified into wet and dry scrubbers. Scrubber water (also known as washwater) from both wet scrubber systems has been found to release acidic water containing nutrients and contaminants back to the marine environment, including metals, aromatic hydrocarbons, and soot particles. This is especially true for the open-loop scrubbers that utilize the natural alkalinity of seawater and keep a high flow of process water in order to reduce SO2 in the exhaust and the washwater is discharged to sea, most often without substantial treatment. Little is known about potential impact of the discharged washwater on the marine environment. In ecotoxicological tests, a number of marine organisms have shown negative effects after acute and chronic exposures to varying concentrations of scrubber water, but the main pollutants involved in these responses are not clear yet. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of the main pollutants found in open-loop scrubber discharge water for survival, feeding and development of different species at the base of the food web after acute exposures to gas scrubber effluent. Toxicity, mortality, and physiology have been evaluated in marine microalgae, Tetraselmis suecica, and blue mussel (Mytilus edulis) larvae. Direct exposure to scrubber water appears to adversely affect biological and reproductive parameters in invertebrates, raising substantial concerns about ongoing open-loop exhaust gas scrubber system deployment.

---

Keywords

• Shipping wastes
• Scrubber water
• Metals
• PAHs
• Tetraselmis suecica
• Mytilus edulis

---

Editorial History

• Received: 26 Jun 2024
• Accepted: 23 Sep 2024
• Available online: 19 Nov 2024

---

References

Abernethy, S., Bobra, A. M., Shiu, W. Y., Wells, P. G., & Mackay. (1986). Acute lethal toxicity of hydrocarbons and chlorinated hydrocarbons to two planktonic crustaceans the key role of water organism-water partitioning. Aquatic Toxicology, 8(3), pp. 163-174

Aksmann, A. and Tukaj, Z. (2004) ‘The effect of anthracene and phenanthrene on the growth, photosynthesis, and SOD activity of the green alga Scenedesmus armatus depends on the PAR irradiance and CO2 level’, Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology, 47(2), pp. 177–184

Aksmann, A. and Tukaj, Z. (2008) ‘Intact anthracene inhibits photosynthesis in algal cells: A fluorescence induction study on Chlamydomonas reinhardtii cw92 strain’, Chemosphere, 74(1), pp. 26–32

Alexander, D. E. (1999). Bioaccumulation, bioconcentration, biomagnification. In: Environmental Geology, Encyclopedia of Earth Science. Dordretch : s.n., pp. 43-44

Andreasen, A. & Mayer, S. (2007). Use of seawater scrubbing for SO2 removal from marine engine exhaust gas. Energy Fuels, 21(6), pp. 3274-3279

Annamaria, V. G., Chiara, L., Alessandra, A. N., Alvise, B., His, E., & Francesco, G. P. (2005). Mytilus galloprovincialis as bioindicator in embryotoxicity testing to evaluate sediment quality in the lagoon of Venice (Italy). Chemistry and Ecology, 21(6), 455-463

Baścik-Remisiewicz, A., Aksmann, A., Zak, A., Kowalska, M. and Tukaj, Z. (2011) ‘Toxicity of cadmium, anthracene, and their mixture to Desmodesmus subspicatus estimated by algal growth-inhibition ISO standard test’, Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology, 60(4), pp. 610–617

Bay, S.M., Oshida, P.S., Jenkins, K.D. (1983). A simple new bioassay based on echinochrome synthesis by larval sea urchin. Marine Environmental Research 8, 29-39

Beaumont, A. R., Tserpes, G., & Budd, M. D. (1987). Some effects of copper on the veliger larvae of the mussel Mytilus edulis and the scallop Pecten maximus (Mollusca, Bivalvia). Marine Environmental Research, 21(4), 299-309

Bellas, J. and Thor, P. (2007) ‘Effects of selected PAHs on reproduction and survival of the calanoid copepod Acartia tonsa’, Ecotoxicology, 16(6), pp. 465–474

Beyer, J., Petersen, K., Song, Y., Ruus, A., Grung, M., Bakke, T. and Tollefsen, K.E. (2014) ‘Environmental risk assessment of combined effects in aquatic ecotoxicology: A discussion paper’, Marine Environmental Research, 96, pp. 81–91

Boese, B. L., Lamberson, J. O., Swartz, R. C. & Ozretich, R. J. (1997). Photoinduced toxicity of fluoranthene to seven benthic crustaceans. Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology , 32(1), pp. 389-393

Boukadida, K., Banni, M., Gourves, P. Y., & Cachot, J. (2016). High sensitivity of embryo-larval stage of the Mediterranean mussel, Mytilus galloprovincialis to metal pollution in combination with temperature increase. Marine Environmental Research, 122, 59-66

Buhaug, O., Fløgstad, H. & Bakke, T. (2006). MARULS WP3: washwater criteria for seawater exhaust gas-SOx scrubbers, Trondheim: Norwegian Marine Technology Research Institute

Campanella, L., Cubadda, F., Sammartino, M. P. & Saoncella, A. (2001). An algal biosensor for the monitoring of water toxicity in estuarine environments. Water Research, 35(1), pp. 69-76

Champan, R. L. (2013). Algae: the world’s most important “plants”—an introduction. Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change, 18(1), pp. 5-12

Chen, C. Y. & Lu, C. L. (2002). An analysis of the combined effects of organic toxicants. Science of the Total Environment, 289(3), pp. 123-132

Cid, Á., Prado, R., Rioboo, C., Suarez-Bregua, P., & Herrero, C. (2012). Use of Microalgae as Biological Indicators of Pollution: Looking for New Relevant Cytotoxicity Endpoints. In: M. N. Johnsen, ed. Microalgae: Biotechnology, Microbiology and Energy. New York: Nova Science Publishers, pp. 311-323

Comer, B., Georgeff, E. and Osipova, L. (2020) Air emissions and water pollution discharges from ships with scrubbers, ICCT CONSULTING REPORT, November 2020. Available at: www.theicct.org (Accessed: 26 March 2021)

Connell, D. W., Yu, Q. J. & Verma, V., 2016. Influence of exposure time on toxicity—An overview. Toxicology, 356(2), pp. 49-53

Connor, P.M. (1972). Acute toxicity of heavy metals to some marine larvae. Marine Pollution Bulletin 3, 190-192

Croxton, A.N., Wikfors, G.H. and Schulterbrandt-Gragg, R.D. (2015) ‘The use of flow cytometric applications to measure the effects of PAHs on growth, membrane integrity, and relative lipid content of the benthic diatom, Nitzschia brevirostris’, Marine Pollution Bulletin, 91(1), pp. 160–165

Davarpanah, E. and Guilhermino, L. (2015) ‘Single and combined effects of microplastics and copper on the population growth of the marine microalgae Tetraselmis chuii’, Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science, 167, pp. 269–275

Debelius, B., Forja, J.M., DelValls, Á. and Lubián, L.M. (2009) ‘Toxicity and bioaccumulation of copper and lead in five marine microalgae’, Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 72(5), pp. 1503–1513

Ebenezer, V. and Ki, J.S. (2013) ‘Quantification of the sub-lethal toxicity of metals and endocrine-disrupting chemicals to the marine green microalga Tetraselmis suecica’, Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 16(3), pp. 187–194

Ebenezer, V. and Ki, J.S. (2016) ‘Toxic effects of Aroclor 1016 and bisphenol A on marine green algae Tetraselmis suecica, diatom Ditylum brightwellii and dinoflagellate Prorocentrum minimum’, Korean Journal of Microbiology, 52(3), pp. 306–312

Echeveste, P., Agustí, S. and Dachs, J. (2010) ‘Cell size dependent toxicity thresholds of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons to natural and cultured phytoplankton populations’, Environmental Pollution, 158(1), pp. 299–307

Echeveste, P., Agustí, S. and Dachs, J. (2011) ‘Cell size dependence of additive versus synergetic effects of UV radiation and PAHs on oceanic phytoplankton’, Environmental Pollution, 159(5), pp. 1307–1316

Endres, S., Maes, F., Hopkins, F., Houghton, K., Mårtensson, E.M., Oeffner, J., Quack, B., Singh, P. and Turner, D. (2018) ‘A new perspective at the ship-air-sea-interface: The environmental impacts of exhaust gas scrubber discharge’, Frontiers in Marine Science, p. 139

Espinoza-González, C., Meynard, A., Núñez, A., Castañeda, F., Oyarzo-Miranda, C., Latorre-Padilla, N., Rivas, J. and Contreras-Porcia, L. (2021) ‘Assessment of the independent and combined effects of copper and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons on gametogenesis and sporophyte development of the kelp Lessonia spicata (Phaeophyceae, Ochrophyta)’, Journal of Applied Phycology, 1, pp. 1–12

Gala, W.R. and Giesy, J.P. (1992) ‘Photo-induced toxicity of anthracene to the green alga, Selenastrum capricornutum’, Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology, 23, pp. 316–323

Gala, W.R. and Giesy, J.P. (1994) ‘Flow cytometric determination of the photoinduced toxicity of anthracene to the green alga Selenastrum capricornutum’, Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry, 13(5), pp. 831–840

Gazeau, F., Parker, L. M., Comeau, S., Gattuso, J. P., O’Connor, W. A., Martin, S., ... & Ross, P. M. (2013). Impacts of ocean acidification on marine shelled molluscs. Marine Biology, 160, 2207-2245

Garr, A.L., Laramore, S. and Krebs, W. (2014) ‘Toxic effects of oil and dispersant on marine microalgae’, Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology, 93(6), pp. 654–659

Gauthier, P.T., Norwood, W.P., Prepas, E.E. and Pyle, G.G. (2014) ‘Metal-PAH mixtures in the aquatic environment: A review of co-toxic mechanisms leading to more-than-additive outcomes’, Aquatic Toxicology, 154, pp. 253–269

Grote, M., Schüürmann, G. and Altenburger, R. (2005) ‘Modeling photoinduced algal toxicity of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons’, Environmental Science and Technology, 39(11), pp. 4141–4149

Hansen, J. P. & Aalborg, A. L. (2012). Exhaust Gas Scrubber Installed Onboard MV Ficaria Seaways : Public Test Report , Environmental Project No. 1429, Copenhagen: Miljøstyrelsen

Hassellöv, I. M., Koski, M., Broeg, K., Marin-Enriquez, O., Tronczynski, J., Dulière, V., ... & Parmentier, K. (2020). ICES Viewpoint background document: Impact from exhaust gas cleaning systems (scrubbers) on the marine environment (Ad hoc). ICES Scientific Reports, 2(86), p. 40

His, E., Beiras, R., & Seaman, M. (1999). The assessment of aquatic contamination: bioassays with bivalve larvae. Advances in Marine Biology, 37, 1-178

Inthorn D. (2001). Removal of heavy metal by using microalgae. Edited by Hiroyuki Kojima and Yuan Kun Lee, Photosynthetic Microorganisms in Environmental Biotechnology. Springer- Verlag Hong Kong Ltd 2001. 310: 111-169

ISO (1989). ISO 8692 Fresh Water Algal Growth Inhibition Test with Scenedesmus subspicatus and Selenastrum capricornutum. , Geneve: International Organization for Standardization

ISO (2015) ISO 17244 Water quality. Determination of the toxicity of water samples on the embryo-larval development of Japanese oyster (Crassostrea gigas) and mussel (Mytilus edulis or Mytilus galloprovincialis). ISO 17244:2015, pp 24

Jajoo, A., Mekala, N. R., Tomar, R. S., Grieco, M., Tikkanen, M., & Aro, E. M. (2014). Inhibitory effects of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) on photosynthetic performance are not related to their aromaticity. Journal of Photochemistry and Photobiology B: Biology, 137(1), pp. 151-155

Jiang, Y., Wu, Z., Han, X. and Zhang, L. (2002) ‘Toxicity of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) to marine algae’, Marine Sciences, 26(1), pp. 46–50. Available at: https://europepmc.org/article/cba/390108

Kjølholt, J., Aakre, S., Jürgensen, C. and Lauridsen, J. (2012) Assessment of possible impacts of scrubber water discharges on the marine environment, Environmental Project No. 1431. Available at: www.mst.dk (Accessed: 9 April 2021)

Koski, M., Stedmon, C., & Trapp, S. (2017). Ecological effects of scrubber water discharge on coastal plankton: Potential synergistic effects of contaminants reduce survival and feeding of the copepod Acartia tonsa. Marine Environmental Research, 129, 374-385

Koski, M., Stedmon, C., & Trapp, S. (2017). Ecological effects of scrubber water discharge on coastal plankton: Potential synergistic effects of contaminants reduce survival and feeding of the copepod Acartia tonsa. Marine Environmental Research, 129, 374-385

Kumar, K.S. and Shin, K.-H. (2017) ‘Effect of Copper on Marine Microalga Tetraselmis suecica and its Influence on Intra- and Extracellular Iron and Zinc Content’, Korean Journal of Ecology and Environment, 50(1), pp. 16–28

Landrum, P. F., Lotufo, G. R., Gossiaux, D. C., Gedeon, M. L., & Lee, J. H. (2003). Bioaccumulation and critical body residue of PAHs in the amphipod, Diporeia spp.: Additional evidence to support toxicity additivity for PAH mixtures. Chemosphere, 51(6), pp. 481-489

Lange, B. and Markus, T. (2015) Impact of Scrubbers on the environmental situation in ports and coastal waters. Available at: http://www.umweltbundesamt.de/sites/default/files/medien/378/publikationen/texte_65_2915_impacts_of_scubbers_on_the_envoronmental_situation_in_ports_and_coastal_waters.pdf (Accessed: 25 April 2021)

Letendre, J., Dupont-Rouzeyrol, M., Hanquet, A. C., Durand, F., Budzinski, H., Chan, P., ... & Rocher, B. (2011). Impact of toxicant exposure on the proteomic response to intertidal condition in Mytilus edulis. Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology Part D: Genomics and Proteomics, 6(4), 357-369

Lindstad, H.E. and Eskeland, G.S. (2016) ‘Environmental regulations in shipping: Policies leaning towards globalization of scrubbers deserve scrutiny’, Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment, 47, pp. 67–76

Lunde Hermansson, A., Hassellöv, I.-M., Moldanová, J. and Ytreberg, E. (2021) ‘Comparing emissions of polyaromatic hydrocarbons and metals from marine fuels and scrubbers’, Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment, 97, p. 102912

Magnusson, K., Thor, P. and Granberg, M. (2018) Scrubbers: Closing the loop Activity 3: Task 2 Risk Assessment of marine exhaust gas scrubber water Evolutionary effects of ocean acidification View project Micropoll-Multilevel assessment of microplastics and associated pollutants in the Baltic Sea View . Available at: www.ivl.se (Accessed: 9 April 2021)

Martin, M., Osborn, K. E., Billig, P., & Glickstein, N. (1981). Toxicities of ten metals to Crassostrea gigas and Mytilus edulis embryos and Cancer magister larvae. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 12(9), 305-308

McCormick, P. V. & Cairns, J. J. (1994). Algae as indicators of environmental change. Journal of Applied Phycology, 6(1), pp. 509-526

Okay, O.S. and Karacik, B. (2007) ‘Photoinduced toxicity of selected PAHs to the marine microalga Phaeodactylum tricornutum’, Journal of Environmental Science and Health - Part A, 42(6), pp. 707–714

Olmstead, A. W. & LeBlanc, G. A. (2005). Joint action of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons: Predictive modeling of sublethal toxicity. Aquatic Toxicology, 75(1), pp. 253-262

Onyena, A. P., Manohar, C. S., Nkwoji, J. A., & Chukwu, L. O. (2024). Characterization of the molecular differential responses in marine benthic macroinvertebrates exposed to polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons Aquatic Ecology, 58(2), 263-288

Othman, H. B., Pick, F. R., Hlaili, A. S., & Leboulanger, C. (2023). Effects of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons on marine and freshwater microalgae–A review. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 441, 129869

Picone, M., Russo, M., Distefano, G. G., Baccichet, M., Marchetto, D., Ghirardini, A. V., ... & Marcomini, A. (2023). Impacts of exhaust gas cleaning systems (EGCS) discharge waters on planktonic biological indicators. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 190, 114846

Pokora, W. and Tukaj, Z. (2010) ‘The combined effect of anthracene and cadmium on photosynthetic activity of three Desmodesmus (Chlorophyta) species’, Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 73(6), pp. 1207–1213

Regoli, F., & Giuliani, M. E. (2014). Oxidative pathways of chemical toxicity and oxidative stress biomarkers in marine organisms. Marine Environmental Research, 93, 106-117

Schmolke, S., Ewert, K., Kaste, M., Schöngaßner, T., Kirchgeorg, T., & Marin-Enriquez, O. (2020). Environmental Protection in Maritime Traffic – Scrubber Wash Water Survey. Final report., Dessau-Roßlau: Umweltbundesamt

Šepič, E., Bricelj, M. and Leskovšek, H. (2003) ‘Toxicity of fluoranthene and its biodegradation metabolites to aquatic organisms’, Chemosphere, 52(7), pp. 1125–1133

Sofiev, M., Winebrake, J.J., Johansson, L., Carr, E.W., Prank, M., Soares, J., Vira, J., Kouznetsov, R., Jalkanen, J.P. and Corbett, J.J. (2018) ‘Cleaner fuels for ships provide public health benefits with climate tradeoffs’, Nature Communications, 9(1)

Spehar, R. L., Poucher, S., Brooke, L. T., Hansen, D. J., Champlin, D., & Cox, D. A. (1999). Comparative toxicity of fluoranthene to freshwater and saltwater species under fluorescent and ultraviolet light. Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology, 37(4), pp. 496-502

Swartz, R. C., Schults, D. W., Ozretich, R. J., Lamberson, J. O., Cole, F. A., Ferraro, S. P., ... & Redmond, M. S. (1995). Ʃ PAH: A model to predict the toxicity of polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbon mixtures in field-collected sediments. Environmental Texicology and Chemistry, 14(11), pp. 1977-1987

Tam, N. F. Y., Wong, Y. S. and Chong, A. M. Y. (2001) ‘Toxic Effect of Tributyltin (TBT) on Different Green Microalgal Species’, Algae and their Biotechnological Potential, pp. 181–194

Teuchies, J., Cox, T.J.S., Van Itterbeeck, K., Meysman, F.J.R. and Blust, R. (2020) ‘The impact of scrubber discharge on the water quality in estuaries and ports’, Environmental Sciences Europe, 32(1)

Thor, P., Granberg, M.E., Winnes, H. and Magnusson, K. (2021) ‘Severe Toxic Effects on Pelagic Copepods from Maritime Exhaust Gas Scrubber Effluents’, Environmental Science and Technology, 55(9), pp. 5826–5835

Tukaj, Z. and Pokora, W. (2006) ‘Individual and combined effect of anthracene, cadmium, and chloridazone on growth and activity of SOD isoforms in three Scenedesmus species’, Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 65(3), pp. 323–331.
DOI 10.1016/j.ecoenv.2005.12.001

Turner, D.R., Hassellöv, I.M., Ytreberg, E. and Rutgersson, A. (2017) ‘Shipping and the environment: Smokestack emissions, scrubbers and unregulated oceanic consequences’, Elementa: Science of the Anthropocene, 5, pp. 1–10.
DOI 10.1525/elementa.167

USEPA (2011) ‘Exhaust Gas Scrubber Washwater Effluent’, p. 46. Available at: https://www3.epa.gov/npdes/pubs/vgp_exhaust_gas_scrubber.pdf (Accessed: 26 March 2021)

Ushakov, S., Stenersen, D., Einang, P. M. & Ask, T. Ø. (2020). Meeting future emission regulation at sea by combining low-pressure EGR and seawater scrubbing. Journal of Marine Science and Technology, 25(2), pp. 482-497

Van der Oost, R., Heida, H. & Opperhuizen, A. (1988). Polychlorinated biphenyl congeners in sediments, plankton, molluscs. crustaceans and eel in a freshwater lake: implications of using reference chemicals and indicator organisms in bioaccumulation studies. Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology, 17(1), pp. 721-729

Verbruggen, E. M. (2012). Environmental risk limits for polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs): For direct aquatic, benthic, and terrestrial toxicity., s.l.: National Institute for Health and Environment. 339p

Viana, M., Hammingh, P., Colette, A., Querol, X., Degraeuwe, B., Vlieger, I. de and van Aardenne, J. (2014) ‘Impact of maritime transport emissions on coastal air quality in Europe’, Atmospheric Environment, pp. 96–105

Vitorino, J. D. B. (2023). Characterisation of Phase I genes from invertebrate detoxification mechanisms: The Mytilus sp. case-study. Available at: https://run.unl.pt/bitstream/10362/163524/1/Vitorino_2023.pdf (Accessed 8 October 2024)

Vlahogianni, T. H., & Valavanidis, A. (2007). Heavy-metal effects on lipid peroxidation and antioxidant defence enzymes in mussels Mytilus galloprovincialis. Chemistry and Ecology, 23(5), 361-371

Wang, L., Zheng, B. and Meng, W. (2008) ‘Photo-induced toxicity of four polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, singly and in combination, to the marine diatom Phaeodactylum tricornutum’, Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 71(2), pp. 465–472

Weinstein, J.E. and Polk, K.D. (2001) ‘Phototoxicity of anthracene and pyrene to glochidia of the freshwater mussel Utterbackia imbecillis’, Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry, 20(9), pp. 2021–2028

Wolska, L., Mechlińska, A., Rogowska, J. and Namieśnik, J. (2012) ‘Sources and fate of PAHs and PCBs in the marine environment’, Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology, pp. 1172–1189

Ytreberg, E., Hassellöv, I. M., Nylund, A. T., Hedblom, M., Al-Handal, A. Y., & Wulff, A. (2019). Effects of scrubber washwater discharge on microplankton in the Baltic Sea. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 145, 316-324

Zhu, J., Lu, Y. and Chen, W. (2008) ‘Single and joint toxic effects of cadmium and phenanthrene on enchytraeid Fridericia bulbosa’, European Journal of Soil Biology, 44(3), pp. 260–265

Related Contents

• BACTERIOLOGICAL EVALUATION IN EXPERIMENTAL LANDFILL CELLS: THE CO-DISPOSAL OF HOUSEHOLD SOLID WASTE AND HEALTHCARE SOLID WASTE

  Bianca Ramalho Quintaes, Marco André Giovannini Hinojosa, Alessandra Fonseca Lourenço, Analy Machado de Oliveira Leite, Marco Antonio Lemos Miguel, João Alberto Ferreira and Juacyara Campos

  Published 19 Nov 2024
• ECONOMIC INSTRUMENTS FOR THE CIRCULAR ECONOMY TRANSITION: THE (NEGLECTED) ROLE OF VIRGIN MATERIALS AND LANDFILL TAXATION IN ITALY

  Andrea Zatti

  Published 19 Nov 2024
• USING EXERGY TO ADDRESS A CIRCULAR ECONOMY

  Marc A. Rosen

  Published 19 Nov 2024

---